Wixen Music Publishing, which represents hits by the likes of Neil
Young and Tom Petty, is suing Spotify for at least $1.6bn – claiming
that the platform is illegally under-paying songwriters while handing
“outrageous annual salaries to its executives”.
The Los
Angeles-based publisher filed a lawsuit on Friday (December 29) in
California alleging that Daniel Ek’s platform is hosting tens of
thousands of Wixen-managed songs without a sufficient mechanical
copyright license.
It seeks statutory damages in excess of $1.6bn – or $150,000 per song – for ‘willful copyright infringement’.
Wixen
– whose repertoire also includes works by The Doors, The Black Keys and
Rage Against The Machine – also seeks to force Spotify to ‘develop and implement procedures for identifying and properly licensing songs’.
The
action has been triggered by the arrival of the US Music Modernization
Act, which was introduced by Congressman Doug Collins in December.
Although Wixen praises the work of the National Music Publishers
Association (NMPA) in helping shape the legislation, the company objects
to one provision which – once the bill becomes law – would affect
publishers’ ability to sue Spotify (and other streaming services) for
infringing mechanical copyrights after the date of January 1, 2018.
Wixen
president Randall Wixen said in a statement today that “unfortunately
the bill disenfranchises our clients from legal redress for
infringements made of their songs without proper licenses by various
streaming services.”
Wixen has declined to participate in a recent
settlement offer from Spotify to a class action led by songwriters
David Lowery and Melissa Ferrick – which accuses Daniel Ek’s company of
infringing mechanical copyrights in the US.
That $43m settlement offer
was made by Spotify in May last year, but Wixen says that ‘the proposed
settlement is inadequate, because too much of [it] is going to legal
fees, and because the terms of the go-forward license in the settlement
are not in [our songwriters’] long-term best interests’.
Wixen
says that it remains keen to find an ‘amicable settlement ‘ with Spotify
for its ‘past infringements and unlicensed uses, and seeks to work out a
go-forward license which is fair to all parties’.
But it has some
very strong words for the streaming platform, which is widely expected
to attempt a stock flotation this year via a ‘direct listing’ on the
NYSE.
Randall Wixen said: “We are very disappointed that these services
will retroactively get a free pass for actions that were previously
illegal unless we actually file suit before January 1, 2018. Neither we
nor our clients are interested in becoming litigants but we have been
faced with a choice of forfeiting rights and damages, or taking action
at this time.
“We regret that this otherwise admirable proposed
bill has had this effect, and we hope that Spotify nonetheless comes to
the table with a fair and reasonable approach to reaching a resolution
with us. We are fully prepared to go as far forward in the courts as
required to protect our clients’ rights.”
Wixen added: “We’re just
asking to be treated fairly. We are not looking for a ridiculous
punitive payment. But we estimate that our clients account for somewhere
between 1% and 5% of the music these services distribute. Spotify has
more than $3 billion in annual revenue and pays outrageous annual
salaries to its executives and millions per month for ultra-luxurious
office space in various cities.
“All we’re asking for is for them
to reasonably compensate our clients by sharing a miniscule amount of
the revenue they take in with the creators of the product they sell.
Music fans should be able to enjoy Spotify, knowing that their favorite
artists are being treated fairly.”
Comments