Skip to main content

TENCENT MUSIC ISN’T ACTUALLY A CHINESE COMPANY. WHY SHOULD THE GLOBAL MUSIC BUSINESS CARE?


Chinese tech and media conglomerate Tencent Holdings, and its music subsidiary Tencent Music, have been making music-business headlines over the past few years.
From Tencent Music inking an equity swap with Spotify and touting an unconventional, tipping-driven business model, to both Sony Music and Warner Music owning stakes in Tencent Music as well, to Tencent Holdings purchasing a minority stake in Universal Music Group and being the target of an antitrust probe from the Chinese government, the global music business is now inseparable from Chinese money.
But there’s one big caveat to this whole narrative: Tencent Music and Tencent Holdings are not actually Chinese companies on paper. Instead, they’re both incorporated in the Cayman Islands — over 8,100 miles away from Beijing.

A British Overseas Territory in the Caribbean Sea with notorious ties to offshore financing and tax fraud (see the Panama Papers and Paradise Papers), the Cayman Islands also serves as the headquarters for many other tech conglomerates in China. Aside from Tencent, the likes of Alibaba, Baidu, JD.com and Sina Corporation also call the territory “home.”
Moreover, because of its offshore incorporation, Tencent Music doesn’t actually own any of the music services it operates — namely QQ Music, Kugou, Kuwo and WeSing — and, crucially, neither do its shareholders.
Instead, Tencent Music merely maintains a series of “contractual arrangements” with said music services through a legal structure known as a variable interest entity (VIE) — which gives the parent company effective operational control over the services and the ability to consolidate their financial and operational results in quarterly financial statements, but does not give Tencent Music’s shareholders any voting rights.
Moreover, many legal sources have previously claimed that due to the relative underdevelopment of securities law in the Cayman Islands, the contracts that Tencent Music holds with its services through VIE arrangements may be unenforceable — or, in legal terms, void ab initio (“to be treated as invalid from the outset”). If accurate, this would leave little to no protection for Tencent Music’s investors, which, remember, include major music-industry stakeholders. The Chinese government has yet to speak out in formal endorsement of VIEs, nor in confirmation of their enforceability.
Why is no one in the music industry talking about this, and what could it mean for their own future?
To start, it’s worth unpacking why in the world Tencent or any of its big-tech peers in China would want to incorporate in the Cayman Islands in the first place, instead of in their own country.
As revealed in part by the investigations of the Paradise Papers and the Panama Papers, the Cayman Islands is a popular offshore tax haven for both wealthy individuals and larger companies from around the world, as the territory charges no income, corporation or capital gains tax. (Two of Spotify’s board members, CEO Daniel Ek and co-founder Martin Lorentzon, have both incorporated their own holding companies — D.G.E. Holding and Rosello, respectively — in the Republic of Cyprus, another popular offshore financial center.)
As Tencent Music discusses in its F-1 filing, incorporating in China would have required the company to pay to a “standard worldwide income tax rate” of 25% as a “resident enterprise” in the People’s Republic of China, a much more expensive situation than the Cayman Islands’ tax-free environment.
Another reason a Chinese company might want to incorporate in the Cayman Islands is to obfuscate its corporate ownership structure. This motivation has precedent among Chinese elites — as the New York Times found in multiple investigations of local conglomerate HNA Group, which used offshore incorporation to help hide the extent to which top executives and their relatives controlled the company and its subsidiaries.
For Tencent, the issue of obfuscating ownership is especially interesting in light of recent rumors that Tencent Holdings turned to sovereign wealth funds from Singapore and other countries to help rescue its equity deal with Universal Music Group, after major potential funders left the negotiating table. At large, territories like the Cayman Islands are now being forced to consider public registries that show who owns all locally-registered companies.
But for most Chinese companies, the top reason to incorporate offshore is purely practical: If they want to achieve a certain level of international scale and popularity through attracting foreign investors, they almost don’t have any other choice.
The Chinese government maintains a list of local business sectors that are restricted from accepting foreign investment — known as the “Special Administrative Measures on Access to Foreign Investment,” or simply as the “Negative List.”
According to Tencent Music’s F-1 filing, the latest version of the list prohibits foreign investors “from investing in companies engaged in certain online and culture related businesses, internet audio-visual programs businesses, internet culture businesses and radio and television program production businesses.”
Music- and audio-streaming platforms are included in this mix. This is likely why, for instance, Spotify has not yet launched in China and decided to invest in Tencent Music instead, as a way of having an upside in the local music market’s growth without dealing with the country’s political complexities directly.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Alibaba Music Mixes Business And Pleasure

Alibaba Music Mixes Business And Pleasure Alibaba Music, Alibaba Group’s music division, has upgraded its music streaming business with the debut of an online platform where fans can connect with stars, merchants and others in the entertainment industry. Through the just-launched Alibaba Planet platform, music fans can use their smartphones to follow their favorite stars, participate in fan activities, purchase related merchandise and watch live shows of cyber celebrities and popular singers, in addition to listening to streaming songs, Alibaba Music said. The platform is built on TTpod (Tiantiandongting), a music streaming app acquired by Alibaba Group in 2013. Alibaba Planet is more than a fan portal, according to the company. The platform is also open to composers, music producers, merchants, and other companies related to the music business that are looking for business opportunities. For instance, singers will be able to find songwriters and merchants will be ...

NETFLIX JUST RAISED ITS PRICES FOR THE THIRD TIME SINCE SPOTIFY LAUNCHED IN THE USA

The words of Spotify CFO Barry McCarthy at Goldman Sachs’s Communacopia conference in September – responding to a query over whether the music streaming company should consider raising its standard $9.99/£9.99/€9.99-per-month premium subscription price in lucrative markets like the US and the UK. McCarthy’s dismissal irritated some of those within record labels, who are increasingly calling into question Spotify’s declining global ARPU (Average Revenue Per paying User) rate. Spotify’s monthly worldwide ARPU has declined dramatically over the past three years, most recently falling to €4.73 ($5.50) in Q3 2018. That was down over €2 per month, or €24 per year, on the equivalent figure at the close of 2015 (€6.84). The key factors in this ARPU decline include Spotify’s pricing in emerging markets, in addition to generous telco bundle agreements, aggressive $0.99-for-three-months Premium price promotions, plus Spotify’s Family and Student plans. One way to push ARPU b...

MASAE GIMBAYASHI – Album « Je te veux »

MASAE GIMBAYASHI – Album « Je te veux » Classic variations Label Plaza Mayor Company Ltd Distribution Sergent Major Company Ltd – The Orchard “In this album improvisation is integrated between Satie and Gershwin, a sign of her unique musicality cultivated in jazz. The music of the past and its "now" light up like a mirror. The selection of music, and of course the performance itself are perfect. The excellent quality of the recording that captures the sound of the piano undoubtedly increases its value. ”- Shin-ichi Numabé music critic, Japan https://open.spotify.com/album/5wP9x6tOBCxwxnxHx10kWU   Masaé GImbayashi Masaé performs in Europe and Japan, USA, invited to the Festivals such as Normandy Impressionist, Albert Roussel Festival, Bray Norman jazz festival, 150th anniversary of Franco-Japanese friendships, 150th opening of the port of Yokohama, Festival des Bell towers... Winner of national and international competitions, student of Jay Go...